Which is better for a first-time self-tanner?

Tan-Luxe The Gradual Illuminating Tanning Lotion is the gentler start because it builds one shade gradually and shows a glow within about an hour. The Self Tanner Body Lotion is also gradual but gives no stated onset time.

Which gives more product for the money?

The Self Tanner Body Lotion: 15 fl oz total for $35.99 at Beauty by Earth as of November 3, 2026. Tan-Luxe is 8.5 fl oz and no price was given here, so compare its current price before deciding.

Which lasts longer between repurchases?

The Self Tanner Body Lotion, at 15 fl oz versus 8.5 fl oz. Tan-Luxe needs reapplication every other day to maintain the glow, which uses it up faster.

Is the Tan-Luxe worth the extra cost?

Only if you want the faster glow and the illuminating finish. If you just want a hydrating everyday tan, the Self Tanner Body Lotion costs less per ounce at the price given.

Which is better for sensitive skin?

The Self Tanner Body Lotion is described as safe for sensitive skin and pregnancy-safe, and it is Leaping Bunny certified. Tan-Luxe lists aloe vera and vegan status but no sensitive-skin claim.

Do either of them smell like self-tanner?

The Self Tanner Body Lotion is scented coconut and fresh with no self-tanner smell, per the brand. Tan-Luxe uses Odourlite Fragrance Technology to mask the DHA smell.

Self Tanner Body Lotion vs Tan-Luxe The Gradual Illuminating Tanning Lotion

Both are gradual, lotion-based tanners, so the choice comes down to size, price and finish. The Beauty by Earth Self Tanner Body Lotion gives you 15 fluid ounces (two 7.5 oz bottles) for $35.99 at Beauty by Earth as of November 3, 2026, and it is the better value for regular full-body use. Tan-Luxe The Gradual Illuminating Tanning Lotion is an 8.5 fl oz oil-lotion hybrid with an illuminating finish and Odourlite fragrance technology, but no price was given for it here, so check its current price before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent