Grain Wood Shaker 5-Piece Bedroom Set vs Clelane 6-Piece Shiplap Queen Suite

Buy the Shaker 5-Piece if you want solid pine throughout, a bed that works without a box spring, and GREENGUARD-certified low-VOC finish. Buy the Clelane 6-Piece if you want a shiplap farmhouse look, a felt-lined top drawer and full-extension dovetail drawers, and you don't mind a required box spring. The Shaker's all-wood build and replaceable metal pulls hold up better over years; the Clelane's drawer hardware and veneer-over-solid construction are the nicer details day to day.

• Choose the Shaker Bedroom Set if you want an all-solid-pine set with a low-VOC, GREENGUARD-certified finish and a bed that doesn't need a box spring.
• Choose the Clelane 6-Piece Suite if you want shiplap farmhouse styling with dovetail, full-extension drawers and a felt-lined top drawer.