Which is better for a beginner?

The Aolikoko kit. It bundles 27 eye shadows and 10 brushes at $19.90, which is cheaper to experiment with. The SHANY set assumes you already have brushes and want full-coverage contouring.

Is the SHANY set worth double the price?

Only if you want full-coverage contour and highlight plus a lipstick in a gift box. At $39.99 versus $19.90, you pay for face coverage and packaging, not for more eye shadows.

Which has more reliable ratings?

The SHANY set, with 126 ratings against 7 for the Aolikoko. But SHANY's average is lower at 3.3 versus 4.3, so read the negative reviews before deciding.

Which is easier to travel with?

The Aolikoko. Its pouch measures 10.4 x 6.5 x 3.74 inches. The SHANY black box is 12 x 10 x 6 inches and is built as a gift set, not a travel case.

Does either set include brushes?

The Aolikoko includes 10 brushes. The SHANY listing names sponge or brush application but does not state that tools are included, so plan to supply your own.

Are the shades the same in every SHANY set?

No. The listing says colors may vary, so the palette you receive can differ from photos. The Aolikoko kit is listed in pink but its shade range is not detailed.

SHANY Bundle Makeup Set vs Aolikoko All-in-One Makeup Kit for Teens & Women

Buy the Aolikoko kit if you want a low-cost starter set with many eye shadows and brushes; buy the SHANY bundle if you want a full-coverage face palette plus lipstick and a gift-ready box. The Aolikoko is about half the price at $19.90, but its 4.3 rating rests on only 7 ratings, while the SHANY's 3.3 comes from 126. Neither has a price history worth waiting on: both have held a single price since late October 2026.

Ask our shopping agent