SHANY Bundle Makeup Set vs MAC Holiday Collection Makeup Set
Buy the SHANY Bundle if you want a large, low-cost gift box of full-size color cosmetics for experimenting with contour and highlight. Buy the MAC Holiday Collection if you want a curated set of named MAC best-sellers and a full-size Fix+ Stay Over. On price, SHANY is $39.99 at Walmart as of November 3, 2026, while no price was given for the MAC set.
Ask our shopping agent
SHANY Bundle Makeup Set
3.3$39.99at WalmartObserved at 9:41 AM
Choose the SHANY Bundle if you want a big, inexpensive gift-box set with full-size palette, lipstick and blush pieces for all-over color play.
Pros
- Full-size pieces in a bulk gift box
- Palette plus lipstick plus blush covers eyes, lips and cheeks
- Cruelty-free and unscented
- Stated for all skin types and tones
- $39.99 at Walmart as of November 3, 2026
Cons
- 3.3 out of 5 from 126 ratings
- Shades may vary, so the exact colors are not guaranteed
What separates them
| SHANY Bundle Makeup Set | MAC Holiday Collection Makeup Set | |
|---|---|---|
| Set size | One bulk set in a 12 x 10 x 6 in black gift box | Seven pieces: six full size plus one sample |
| Brand reputation in color cosmetics | SHANY, a budget multi-brand set maker | MAC, an established pro makeup brand |
| Product mix | Palette, lipstick and powder blush with shimmer highlight and contour | Lipstick, eye shadow duo, mascara, liner and Fix+ Stay Over |
| Full-size vs sample | Full-size pieces sold in bulk | Six full size, one Artist-fave sample; lipsticks are 0.01 oz |
| Finish | Shimmer highlight and contour | Not specified; MAC best-sellers span matte and gloss |
| Skin type and tone | Stated for all skin types and tones | Not stated in the listing |
| Cruelty-free claim | Listed as cruelty-free and unscented |
Price history
$39.99$25.00
- SHANY Bundle Makeup Set: lowest $39.99 on Oct 30 at Walmart; $39.99 on Nov 3.
- MAC Holiday Collection Makeup Set: lowest $25.00 on Nov 1.
Prices at every store
SHANY Bundle Makeup Set
- WalmartNew
In stock
$39.99Observed at 9:41 AM - TargetNew
In stock
$49.98Observed at 9:41 AM - eBayNew
Availability unknownSold by makeupandgiftshop2014
$49.98Observed at 9:41 AM
Also available at
- eBayCheck price at eBay
- neoprint.ltCheck price at neoprint.lt
- Top Crew AviationCheck price at Top Crew Aviation
Specs compared
| Spec | SHANY Bundle Makeup Set | MAC Holiday Collection Makeup Set |
|---|---|---|
| Color | Color May vary | — |
| Coverage Level | Full | — |
| Primary Effect | Highlighter, Contour | — |
| Primary Finish | Shimmer | — |
| Form Type | Palette, Lipstick | — |
| Best For Skin Type | All | — |
| Body Part Use | Lips, Eyes | — |
| Application Method | Sponge, Brush | — |
| Unscented | Yes | — |
| Powder Type | Powder (blushes) | — |
| Primary Benefit |
Questions and answers
- Which set is better for a gift?
- The SHANY Bundle is the easier gift pick: it is a full-size bulk set in a black gift box at $39.99 at Walmart as of November 3, 2026. The MAC set is smaller but carries a known brand name.
- Which has more full-size products?
- SHANY sells full-size pieces in bulk. MAC gives six full-size items plus one sample, but its two lipsticks are only 0.01 oz each.
- Is the MAC set worth the extra money?
- No price was given for the MAC set, so a direct value call is not possible. You are paying for the MAC name and a full-size Fix+ Stay Over rather than volume.
- Which is better for oily or sensitive skin?
- SHANY states it suits all skin types and is unscented and cruelty-free. MAC does not state skin type suitability for this set.
- Which lasts longer?
- MAC's Retro Matte lipstick and Fix+ Stay Over are known for long wear. SHANY's shimmer highlight and contour are powder-based and likely need touch-ups.
- Can I use both sets together?
- Yes. SHANY covers highlight, contour and blush, while MAC adds mascara, liner and setting spray, so they overlap little.