Levain Bakery Signature Cookie Assortment vs Cheryl's Cookies Buttercream Cookies Assortment

Buy the Levain assortment if you want big, gooey, bakery-style cookies and a gift that looks and tastes like a New York original. Buy Cheryl's if you want variety, longer shelf life and individually wrapped cookies that ship well and keep. Levain wins on size, texture and gift appeal; Cheryl's wins on variety, storage and durability. Reviewers praise Levain's 6-ounce cookies for arriving fresh and gooey after warming, while Cheryl's fans like the frosted buttercream flavors and freezer-friendly wrapping.

• Choose the Levain Signature Cookie Assortment if you want four big, gooey bakery cookies per box and a gift that feels special to open.
• Choose the Cheryl's Buttercream Cookies Assortment if you want twelve individually wrapped cookies in eleven flavors that keep and freeze well.