Ashley Caitbrook 7-Piece Dining Set vs Picket House Rizzo 7-Piece Dining Set

Buy the Caitbrook if you want a rectangular table that fits a narrow room and chairs with foam cushions and nailhead trim. Buy the Rizzo if you prefer a square pedestal table and chairs on casters that roll out of the way. The Caitbrook has a veneer-over-engineered-wood top and a 4.1-out-of-5 rating from 244 reviews, so owner feedback is easy to check. The Rizzo is solid wood with a one-year limited warranty, but it has no leaf and no published review score.

• Choose the Caitbrook if you need a 60-inch rectangular table for a long wall or narrow dining room and want cushioned, nailhead-trimmed chairs.
• Choose the Rizzo if you want a square pedestal table with fully upholstered channel-back chairs on casters that move easily.