Ashley Caitbrook 7-Piece Dining Set vs Picket House Keaton 5-Piece Round Dining Set

Pick the Caitbrook if you regularly seat six and want upholstered chairs with nailhead trim. Pick the Keaton if your room is small or you prefer a round pedestal table that tucks into a corner. The Caitbrook is the sturdier, more finished set, with a 60-inch rectangular top and foam-cushioned linen-weave seats; owners rate it about 4.1 out of 5 across 244 reviews, with complaints mostly about assembly and the gray wash looking lighter than photos. The Keaton is a four-seat round set with acacia veneer, a cross-back chair design and a pedestal base, and it fits tighter spaces better. Neither is extendable, so seating capacity is fixed.

• Choose the Caitbrook if you need to seat six, want cushioned upholstered chairs, and have room for a 60-inch rectangular table.
• Choose the Keaton if you seat four or fewer, want a round pedestal table for a small or open dining area, and prefer wood cross-back chairs over upholstery.