Which ring is better for a 2-year-old?

The Parkhill silver ring. It comes in sizes 2–5, is hypoallergenic, and costs $25.00–$27.00, which suits a child who will outgrow it fast. The gold ring starts at size 3 1/2, which may be loose on a 2-year-old.

Is the gold ring worth the extra money?

Yes if you want a keepsake. It is solid 14K gold with a genuine birthstone and a lifetime warranty, at $159 at Distritech as of November 3. The silver ring uses cubic zirconia and has no stated warranty.

Which one lasts longer?

The 14K gold ring. Gold does not tarnish, and the ring carries a lifetime manufacturer warranty for defects. Sterling silver tarnishes and is softer, so the silver ring will show wear sooner.

Will the silver ring irritate sensitive skin?

It is marketed as 100% hypoallergenic with no nickel or brass, which is the usual cause of reactions. The gold ring makes no hypoallergenic claim, though 14K gold is generally well tolerated.

Can I get the gold ring in a smaller size?

No. The Loveivy ring is sold only in size 3 1/2. If you need size 2, 4 or 5, the Parkhill ring covers those sizes.

Which has better ratings?

The Parkhill ring has 27 ratings averaging 4.9 out of 5. The Loveivy ring has 3 ratings at 5 out of 5, a much smaller sample.

Size 3 1/2 Children's 14K Yellow Gold Heart Shaped Genuine Birthstone Ring vs Simulated Birthstone Heart Solitaire Size 2-5 Baby / Kids Ring - Sterling Silver

Buy the Loveivy 14K gold ring for a keepsake gift that can be handed down, and the Parkhill sterling silver ring for a first ring a toddler will outgrow in a year or two. The gold ring runs about $159 at Distritech as of November 3, while the silver ring has traded between $25.00 and $27.00 since November 1. The gold ring is the better long-term buy; the silver ring is the better value for very young children.

Ask our shopping agent