Sorel Out N About III Classic vs Sorel Out N About IV Classic Boot

Both are Sorel's waterproof Out N About ankle boots, so the real choice is between the proven III Classic and the newer IV. The III Classic is the safer pick: a removable EVA footbed, a roomier shaft and a long record of owners calling it sneaker-like and light. The IV adds Sorel's STEADYSOLE footbed and EVERTREAD outsole and a taller shaft, but its 3.9 rating and complaints about heel wear, splitting rubber seals and a flat insole make it a step down in durability. Buy the III for all-day walking and wet commutes; buy the IV only if you want the taller collar and the newer sole tech.

• Choose the Out N About III Classic if you want the lighter, more comfortable boot with a removable footbed and a strong record for everyday rain and errands.
• Choose the Out N About IV Classic if you want a taller 5-inch shaft for more ankle coverage and Sorel's newer STEADYSOLE footbed and EVERTREAD outsole.