Sorel Women's Tofino II vs Baffin Icefield Women's Boots

The Baffin Icefield is the warmer, tougher boot, rated for extreme cold and tested at both poles, with a tall shaft and a removable multi-layer liner. The Sorel Tofino II is the lighter, more casual winter boot with a quilted leather-and-canvas look and faux fur cuff, suited to everyday city winters. Reviewers rate both well, with the Icefield slightly ahead on satisfaction. Buy the Sorel for style and daily wear; buy the Baffin for real cold and low-activity standing around outdoors.

• Choose the Sorel Tofino II if you want a lighter, better-looking winter boot for commuting, errands and moderate cold.
• Choose the Baffin Icefield if you face deep cold, snow and ice, or long stretches standing still outdoors.