STAINMASTER PetProtect Baxter II Carpet vs STAINMASTER PetProtect Baxter III Carpet

Both are STAINMASTER PetProtect textured nylons with the same pet-hair release and stain story, so the choice comes down to weight and feel. The Baxter III Trixie is the heavier, denser carpet at 53.6-oz face weight and a 0.73-in pile, which generally means a plusher feel and better crush recovery in busy rooms. The Baxter II Harley is lighter at 40.9-oz and 2301 density with a 0.64-in pile, and its darker Harley colorway hides dirt and pet messes better than the off-white Trixie. Buy the III for comfort and longevity in main living areas; buy the II where traffic is heavy and a darker, easier-to-keep color matters more than softness.

• Choose the Baxter II Harley if you want a darker, dirt-hiding color and a slightly lower pile that stands up to heavy traffic and stairs.
• Choose the Baxter III Trixie if you want the denser, plusher carpet and a lighter off-white look in bedrooms and living rooms.