STAINMASTER PetProtect Baxter II Carpet vs STAINMASTER PetProtect Baxter III Carpet

Both are STAINMASTER PetProtect textured nylon carpets with the same pet-stain and pet-hair story, so the real split is density versus softness. The Baxter II Roscoe is denser (2301) with a 40.9-oz face weight and a 0.62-in pile, which holds up better in hallways and on stairs. The Baxter III Trixie is plusher at 0.73 in with a 53.6-oz face weight, so it feels softer underfoot but packs down more in high-traffic spots. Buy the II for traffic and the III for comfort in low-traffic rooms.

• Choose the Baxter II Roscoe if you want the denser, firmer build for hallways, stairs and busy rooms, and a gray that hides dirt and pet hair.
• Choose the Baxter III Trixie if you want a softer, deeper pile underfoot in bedrooms and living rooms and prefer a light off-white look.