STAINMASTER PetProtect Baxter II Carpet vs STAINMASTER PetProtect Baxter Carpet

Both are STAINMASTER PetProtect nylon carpets with the same stain and pet-hair story, so the real split is density and pile. Baxter II Roscoe is the denser, taller option at 40.9 oz face weight, 0.62 in pile and 2301 density, which gives a fuller, softer floor that holds up better in busy rooms. Baxter I Doberman is lighter at 34.1 oz and 0.53 in pile, so it feels flatter and is the easier pick for tight spaces, stairs or a lower-profile look. Owners of PetProtect nylon generally report easy vacuuming and good stain release; neither is waterproof or antimicrobial, and both rely on the cushion for odor control.

• Choose the Baxter II Roscoe if you want the denser, plusher carpet for a main living room or hallway and prefer a gray tone.
• Choose the Baxter I Doberman if you want a lower, flatter pile for stairs, a basement or a brown-toned room.