Staub Le Cocotte Cast Iron Dutch Oven vs Staub Round Dutch Oven 4 QT
Both are Staub enameled cast iron cocottes made in France with the same black matte enamel, spiked self-basting lid and 500°F lid rating, so build and cooking performance are effectively identical. The real decision is size: the 5.5 qt serves 5-6 and handles whole chickens, large batches of chili and family braises, while the 4 qt serves up to 4 and suits smaller households, sides and everyday stews. Owners rate both highly; the 5.5 qt carries a 4.9 average across 629 ratings, and 4 qt buyers praise the size and browning but some report small rim chips and interior bumps. Buy the larger one unless you cook for one or two and want a lighter, easier-to-store pot.
- Choose the Staub Le Cocotte 5.5 qt if you cook for five or six, want to braise a whole chicken or batch-cook stews and chili with leftovers.
- Choose the Staub 4 qt cocotte if you cook for up to four, want a lighter pot that stores easily and still browns and braises like the larger one.
Prices
- Staub Le Cocotte Cast Iron Dutch Oven: $115.99 at eBay (checked today)
- Staub Round Dutch Oven 4 QT: $149.95 at Atlanta Grill Company (checked today)
- Difference: the Staub Le Cocotte Cast Iron Dutch Oven is $33.96 cheaper than the Staub Round Dutch Oven 4 QT today

