Which is better for office wear?

The Paul Fredrick. It is a non-iron button-down dress shirt in trim or standard fit, while the Stetson is a casual western snap shirt.

The Paul Fredrick has a large track record, but some buyers report the collar splitting at the band after about a year or 10-12 washes. The Stetson has only one rating, so there is little evidence either way.

Is the Stetson true to size?

Buyers say it runs larger than a normal shirt. Consider sizing down, especially since it has a loose classic cut.

Do I need to iron the Paul Fredrick shirt?

No. It is non-iron 2-ply cotton. Machine wash warm and tumble dry.

Which is worth the extra money?

It depends on use. For daily office wear the Paul Fredrick's non-iron finish and fit options justify more. For casual western wear, the Stetson's snaps and styling are the point.

Does the Stetson have a dress version?

No. It is a western snap shirt with pearl snaps and smile pockets, not a dress shirt.

Stetson Men's Western Snap Button Down Shirt vs Non-Iron Cotton Pinpoint Solid Button Down Collar Dress Shirt - White

Buy the Paul Fredrick non-iron pinpoint if you need a crisp white dress shirt for work or formal wear; it has 2,617 ratings at 4.7 and comes in trim and standard fits. Buy the Stetson if you want a western shirt with pearl snaps and smile pockets for casual or rodeo wear. The Stetson is a single 4-out-of-5 rating, so its track record is thin. Check current prices at each store before deciding; no price was provided for either shirt.

Ask our shopping agent