Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Cotton Dress Shirt vs Paul Fredrick Non-Iron Pinpoint Dress Shirt

Buy the white pinpoint (B) for the better fabric, the two-button adjustable mitered cuff and the far larger track record of owner feedback. Buy the navy contrast-trim shirt (A) if you want a darker, more distinctive shirt with contrast inside the neckband and cuffs and a single-button cuff. Both are non-iron cotton button-downs from the same maker with split yokes, top center plackets and longer tails. B's pinpoint weave is 2-ply and feels denser; A's poplin is lighter and crisper. The main knock on B is the collar splitting at the band after about a year of washing, and the main knock on A is tight buttonholes that loosen with use.

• Choose the navy contrast-trim shirt if you want a darker shirt with contrast fabric inside the neckband and cuffs and a plain button cuff.
• Choose the white pinpoint shirt if you want a denser 2-ply fabric, an adjustable two-button cuff and the option of trim or standard fit.