Stewart Freeze Dried Beef Liver Dog Treats vs Pupford Freeze-Dried Training Treats

Both are single-purpose freeze-dried training treats, and the choice comes down to protein and piece count. Stewart is one ingredient, beef liver, with about 75 pieces per 3.5 oz pouch and a strong liver smell that dogs find hard to resist. Pupford packs over 475 sub-calorie chicken treats into a 4 oz bag, which suits long training sessions and puppies. Owners rate both highly; Stewart's 4.6 average reflects complaints about the odor and pieces too large for small mouths, while Pupford's near-perfect score comes with fewer reviews.

• Choose the Stewart if you want a one-ingredient beef liver treat that doubles as a meal topper and your dog is not put off by a strong liver scent.
• Choose the Pupford if you train often and want hundreds of tiny, under-1-calorie chicken rewards from a bag that lasts.