Stewart Freeze Dried Beef Liver Dog Treats vs PureBites Lamb Freeze-Dried Dog Treats

Both are freeze-dried liver treats, so the choice comes down to protein and ingredient count. Stewart is single-ingredient beef liver with a strong following (4.6 from 585 ratings) and up to 75 pieces per pouch, and owners say dogs love it, including picky eaters. PureBites Lamb scores higher on ratings (4.9 from 52) and is a leaner, lower-calorie reward, but its listing shows 19 ingredients with 18% broccoli and apple, so it is not truly single-ingredient despite the label. Buy Stewart for a simple beef liver reward in bulk pieces; buy PureBites Lamb if you want a lamb protein and smaller, lower-calorie treats.

• Choose the Stewart if your dog does well on beef liver and you want a straightforward single-ingredient treat that breaks into training pieces.
• Choose the PureBites Lamb if you want a lamb-based, lower-calorie reward and a smaller treat for a dog on a restricted diet.