Which is better for hot sleepers?

The Eddie Bauer. Its percale weave is crisp and breathable, while the Superior flannel is brushed to hold warmth.

Which fits a thick mattress?

The Superior. It fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep; the Eddie Bauer tops out at 16 inches.

Is the Eddie Bauer worth paying more for?

If prices are close, yes for most people: it has a higher thread count, OEKO-TEX certification and a 5.0 rating versus 4.1. Compare live prices at your stores before deciding.

Percale generally holds up better over years of washing. Flannel is softer but more prone to pilling and thinning.

Does either come in California King?

The Superior does. Eddie Bauer's listed sizes do not include California King.

Which is better for winter?

The Superior flannel, which is brushed for warmth. The Eddie Bauer percale is the cooler choice.

Superior Solid Flannel Cotton Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Sunflower Cotton Sheet Set

Buy the Eddie Bauer Sunflower set if you want crisp, breathable percale with a 200 thread count, OEKO-TEX certification and a 5.0 rating from 937 buyers. Buy the Superior Solid Flannel set if you sleep cold, need an 18-inch deep pocket, or want sizes beyond what Eddie Bauer lists. The Eddie Bauer is the stronger pick for most shoppers; check current prices at your stores before deciding, since neither listing gave a price here.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.