Which is better for a hot sleeper?

The Eddie Bauer Peached Percale. Percale is a plain, crisp weave that breathes, while the Superior set is brushed flannel built to trap warmth.

Which fits a thick mattress?

The Superior set, at up to 18 inches deep. The Eddie Bauer set tops out at 16 inches, so measure your mattress and topper first.

Is the higher thread count better?

Not automatically. Eddie Bauer's 180 beats Superior's 145, but flannel is measured differently and feels heavier, not finer. Pick by warmth, not the number.

Percale generally holds up better to repeated washing without pilling. Flannel is softer but tends to pill and thin with age, so expect the Eddie Bauer set to wear longer.

Is the Eddie Bauer set worth choosing over the higher-rated Superior?

Yes, if you sleep hot or want certified cotton. Otherwise the Superior set wins on fit range, size options, and a much larger rating base.

Do either come in California King?

The Superior set does, along with Twin XL. Eddie Bauer's listed sizes don't include California King.

Superior Solid Flannel Cotton Sheet Set vs Eddie Bauer Peached Percale Sheet Set

Buy the Superior Solid Flannel set for cold rooms and thick mattresses: it fits up to 18 inches deep, comes in six sizes, and has a higher rating from far more buyers. Buy the Eddie Bauer Peached Percale set if you sleep hot and want a crisp, lightweight cotton that is OEKO-TEX certified. The Superior set is the safer pick overall, and its larger rating base makes its 4.1 more reliable than Eddie Bauer's 3.7 from 135 ratings.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.