Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover vs J.Crew Fair Isle Wide Mock-Neck Sweater

Both are relaxed-fit wool-blend pullovers that hit at the hip and need hand washing. The J.Crew Fair Isle has the higher wool share (56% merino, lambswool and alpaca combined versus 40% on the BloomChic) and a wide mock neck, so it feels warmer and more substantial. The BloomChic Supersoft runs longer in the body, comes in sizes 10-30, and adds shoulder buttons and a cable texture. Pick the J.Crew for warmth and a classic patterned look; pick the BloomChic for size range and a softer, drapier hand.

• Choose the Supersoft pullover if you wear a size above 16, want a longer hip-length body, or prefer a soft cable knit with shoulder buttons over a patterned yoke.
• Choose the J.Crew Fair Isle sweater if you want more wool for warmth, a wide mock neck, and a patterned knit that reads as a classic winter sweater.