StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover vs J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover

The J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck is the better everyday sweater: a longer, oversized cut with a classic crewneck and a cotton-wool blend that holds up to regular wear. The BloomChic pullover is the pick for mid and plus sizes up to 30 and for anyone who wants a cable-knit texture with a shoulder button detail. Both are hand wash only, and neither is a heavy winter knit.

  • Choose the Supersoft pullover if you wear a size 10 to 30, want a cable-knit look with shoulder buttons, and prefer a hip-length relaxed fit.
  • Choose the J.Crew crewneck if you want an oversized, below-hip sweater in a plain crewneck that layers easily over shirts.

Prices

  • Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover: $41.31 at BloomChic (last seen Nov 10)
  • J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover: $40.00 at Poshmark (last seen Nov 10)
  • Difference: the J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover is $1.31 cheaper than the Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover at the latest prices (Nov 10)
S
Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover

Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover

$41.31at BloomChicChecked 14 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit BloomChic
Pros
  • Merino and alpaca make up 40% of the blend, so it is warmer than the fiber list suggests
  • Elastane adds stretch and helps the knit keep its shape
  • Cable texture and shoulder buttons give it more detail than a plain crewneck
  • Sized up to 30 for mid and plus-size shoppers
Cons
  • Hand wash only
  • At 20 1/2 inches it sits at the hip, shorter than many oversized sweaters
  • Polyamide is the largest single fiber, so it is not a pure wool knit
  • No pockets
J.Crew
J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover

J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover

$40.00at PoshmarkChecked 14 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Poshmark
Pros
  • Oversized cut with a 25 1/2 inch body covers the hip and layers well
  • Cotton-wool blend suits mild weather and indoor wear
  • Ribbed hem and cuffs hold their shape
  • Plain crewneck works with casual and work outfits
Cons
  • Hand wash only
  • Cotton-heavy blend is lighter and less warm than a wool-rich knit
  • Oversized fit runs roomy, so sizing down is common
  • No plus-size range comparable to the BloomChic run

What separates them

Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit PulloverJ.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover
Size rangeSizes 10 to 30, cut for mid and plus sizesStandard J.Crew size run
Knit styleCable knit with shoulder button detailPlain lightweight knit, ribbed hem and cuffs
Fit and lengthRelaxed, 20 1/2 inch body, hits at hipOversized, 25 1/2 inch body, hits below hip
Fiber blend56% polyamide, 30% merino, 10% alpaca, 4% elastane38% cotton, 29% wool, 24% polyester, 9% alpaca
WarmthWool-rich with elastane for stretch and recoveryCotton-heavy, lighter weight
CareHand washHand wash
NecklinePullover with buttoned shoulderClassic crewneck

Price history

$278.00$40.00
Nov 9Nov 11
  • Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover: lowest $41.31 on Nov 11 at BloomChic.
  • J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover: lowest $40.00 on Nov 11 at Poshmark.

Prices at every store

Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover

  • BloomChicNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $41.31Checked 14 h ago
    Visit BloomChic

Also available at

  • BloomChicCheck price at BloomChic
Prices and history →

J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover

  • PoshmarkNew

    In stock

    $40.00Checked 14 h ago
    Visit Poshmark
  • J.CrewNew

    In stock

    $278.00+ $5.00 shippingChecked 14 h ago
    Visit J.Crew

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 2 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecSupersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit PulloverJ.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover
Material composition56% polyamide/30% merino wool/10% alpaca/4% ela…38% cotton/29% wool/ 24% polyester/9% alpaca
FitRelaxed fitOversized fit
Body length20 1/2"25 1/2"
Sleeve length30"31 1/2"
LengthHits at hipHits below hip
CareHand washHand wash

What reviewers say

J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover

Owners of J.Crew's relaxed knit crewnecks generally like the slouchy shape and softness of the wool-alpaca blend. Common complaints center on pilling and the hand-wash care.

What people mention
  • FitMixedOwners like the oversized drape but some find it too boxy on smaller frames.
  • SoftnessPraisedThe wool and alpaca blend feels softer and warmer than plain cotton knits.
  • PillingCriticisedSome owners report pilling after a few wears, likely from the synthetic share of the blend.
  • CareCriticisedHand washing only is seen as a hassle for an everyday sweater.

Questions and answers

Which is warmer?
The BloomChic pullover. Merino and alpaca make up 40% of its blend, against 38% wool and alpaca combined in the J.Crew, which is cotton-heavy and described as lightweight.
Which fits larger?
The J.Crew. It is an oversized fit with a 25 1/2 inch body that hits below the hip; the BloomChic is relaxed with a 20 1/2 inch body that hits at the hip.
Which is better for plus sizes?
The BloomChic pullover, which is cut for mid and plus-size women and runs from size 10 to 30. The J.Crew comes in a standard size run.
Do either machine wash?
No. Both are labeled hand wash only.
Is the J.Crew worth stepping up to?
If you want an oversized, below-hip crewneck for layering, yes. If you want warmth, cable texture or a wider size range, the BloomChic is the stronger choice.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • J.Crew Fair Isle Wide Mock-Neck Sweater vs J.Crew Relaxed Crewneck Pullover
  • Supersoft Button Detail Shoulder Cable Knit Pullover vs J.Crew Fair Isle Wide Mock-Neck Sweater

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best soft women's sweaters