adidas Terrex Agravic GTX Trail Shoe vs ASICS Gel-Trabuco 12

Both are 8 mm-drop trail shoes with waterproof or protective builds, but they aim at different runners. The Terrex Agravic GTX is the pick for wet, cold, muddy days: the GORE-TEX Invisible Fit membrane and gusseted tongue keep water out, and Continental rubber with 4 mm lugs grips slick rock and root. The Gel-Trabuco 12 is the better all-round trail shoe in dry or mixed conditions: FF Blast foam and rearfoot GEL give softer landings, and the rock protection plate shields the forefoot on rocky ground. Owners of the adidas praise its weatherproofing and grip; ASICS buyers rate the Trabuco's comfort and durability over long miles.

• Choose the Terrex Agravic GTX if you run trails in rain, mud or cold and want a fully waterproof shoe with sure grip on wet rock.
• Choose the Gel-Trabuco 12 if you want a cushioned, plated trail shoe for rocky, dry-to-mixed terrain and long days on your feet.