The North Face Chilkat V Lace-Up vs Sorel Caribou Horizon GTX

The Chilkat V is the better pick for real winter hiking and snowshoeing: its molded TPU heel clip, seam-sealed suede and Surface CTRL winter rubber are built for cold trail work. The Caribou Horizon GTX is the more comfortable everyday winter boot, with a Gore-Tex membrane and a removable Ortholite footbed. Owners of the Chilkat line praise warmth and grip but note the boots run heavy and stiff at first; Caribou owners like the plush liner and easy on-off, though the leather upper needs care.

• Choose the Chilkat V if you want one boot for snowy trails, snowshoeing and cold commutes with a heel clip and aggressive winter rubber.
• Choose the Caribou Horizon GTX if you want a lighter, more flexible winter boot with proven Gore-Tex waterproofing for town and casual wear.