Rothy's Original Slip On Sneaker vs Kizik Freedom Run Sneakers

The Rothy's Original Slip On is the better pick for a washable, knit casual shoe that goes with everything and needs no socks fuss. The Kizik Freedom Run is the better pick for anyone who wants a real athletic shoe with hands-free step-in, a cushioned running-style midsole and a bungee lace system. On build, Rothy's is a soft knit upper on a rubber outsole; Kizik is engineered mesh over a VivaFoam midsole with an Ortholite insole and a full rubber outsole. Owners of the Rothy's praise comfort and washability but report inconsistent sizing, heel rubbing without socks and occasional shrinking after washing; Kizik buyers mostly confirm the hands-free fit works as advertised.

• Choose the Rothy's Original Slip On if you want a machine-washable knit sneaker for casual wear, travel and long walking days, and you will wear it with no-show socks.
• Choose the Kizik Freedom Run if you want a hands-free step-in shoe with athletic cushioning for errands, walking or light running, or if bending down to tie shoes is hard.