Rothy's Original Slip On Sneaker vs Skechers Slip-ins Arch Fit Arcade

The Rothy's Original Slip On is the better pick for women who want a light, packable, machine-washable knit sneaker that looks clean with most outfits. The Skechers Slip-ins Arch Fit Arcade is the stronger choice for arch support, hands-free entry and all-day standing, and it carries the APMA seal. Rothy's buyers praise comfort and washability but report inconsistent sizing, heel rubbing and occasional shrinkage after washing. Skechers owners rate it very highly, though its rating comes from far fewer reviews.

• Choose the Rothy's Original Slip On if you want a soft knit slip-on you can machine wash, wear barefoot on long flights, and pair with almost anything.
• Choose the Skechers Slip-ins Arch Fit Arcade if you need podiatrist-certified arch support, a removable insole and step-in entry without bending down.