Which is better for a weekend trip?

Both fit a weekend. The Polare states 42L, while the Weekender does not state capacity but measures slightly taller at 11.75 in versus 10.6 in. The Weekender is lighter to carry and has more pockets.

Which holds up better in rain?

The Weekender. Its waxed canvas shell is described as waterproof. The Polare is full-grain leather with no waterproof claim, so treat it before wet trips.

Is the Polare worth the extra $10?

If you want an all-leather bag that ages into a patina, yes. At $199.99 at Amazon versus $189.95 at Western Leather Goods, the gap is small. If you want less weight and more pockets, the Weekender wins.

Which is lighter to carry through an airport?

The Weekender at 3.75 lbs versus about 4.85 lbs for the Polare. Both have padded, detachable shoulder straps and a way to attach to rolling luggage.

Do both fit in an overhead bin?

The Polare is marketed as TSA friendly and the Weekender as carry-on luggage. Check your airline's size limit: the Weekender is 23 x 10 x 11.75 in and the Polare 23 x 9.8 x 10.6 in.

What warranty do they have?

Both carry a one-year warranty, the Weekender from Western Leather Goods and the Polare from its manufacturer.

Waxed Canvas Leather Weekender Duffel vs Polare Full Grain Leather Weekender

Buy the Weekender if you want a lighter bag with more pockets, a waterproof waxed-canvas shell and a trolley sleeve. Buy the Polare if you want an all-leather bag with a bigger stated capacity and a TSA-friendly carry-on claim. The Weekender is $189.95 at Western Leather Goods as of November 5, 2026; the Polare is $199.99 at Amazon as of the same date, so the Weekender is about $10 cheaper.

Today the Waxed Canvas Leather Weekender Duffel costs $10.04 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.