Which is better for weekend trips?

Both fit a weekend of clothes. The Weekender is lighter and has a trolley sleeve for pairing with a suitcase. The Saddleback holds a week of clothes for its size but weighs more.

Is the Saddleback worth the extra $529?

Only if you want full-grain leather and a 100-year warranty. The Weekender covers the same trips for $189.95 and is waterproof.

Which is better as a carry-on?

The Weekender, mainly for its trolley sleeve. The Saddleback fits overhead bins but has no sleeve to slide over a suitcase handle.

The Saddleback, on paper. Full-grain leather with riveted stress points and a 100-year warranty outlasts waxed canvas, which needs re-waxing.

Which handles rain better?

The Weekender. Its waxed canvas finish is waterproof. The Saddleback's leather and stainless hardware resist corrosion but are not waterproof.

Which has more pockets?

The Weekender, with four exterior zippered pockets and a large rear zippered pocket. The Saddleback has two deep inset front pockets and one open interior pocket.

Waxed Canvas Leather Weekender Duffel vs Saddleback Leather Deep Pocket Duffle

Buy The Weekender if you want a waterproof carry-on duffel with a trolley sleeve and four exterior pockets for under $200. Buy the Saddleback Deep Pocket Duffle if you want a full-grain leather bag with a 100-year warranty and a Gladstone opening you can pack without zippers. The price gap is wide: $189.95 at Western Leather Goods versus $719.00 at Saddleback Leather, both as of November 5, 2026.

Today the Waxed Canvas Leather Weekender Duffel costs $529.05 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.