Tiffany T Smile Pendant vs HDI Sterling Silver Diamond Heart Pendant

Buy the Tiffany T Smile if you want a fine-jewelry piece in solid 18k gold that holds its finish and can be worn daily for years. Buy the HDI heart if you want a diamond look and are fine with sterling silver and plated rhodium. The Tiffany is the better-made piece; the HDI gives you stones and a heart shape for a fraction of the outlay. Owners of Tiffany T pieces praise the finish and layering; HDI-style silver pendants draw complaints about plating wear and small, included stones.

• Choose the Tiffany T Smile if you want solid 18k gold, a designer motif, and a pendant built to last and layer.
• Choose the HDI heart if you want a diamond-accented heart pendant and sterling silver is acceptable to you.