Which is better for everyday wear?

The Tiffany pendant. It is 18k gold with an adjustable chain and no buyer complaints about the chain breaking. Macy's buyers repeatedly call its chain very thin and prone to breaking.

Which has a real gemstone?

Only the Macy's pendant. It comes with a lab-grown birthstone or lab-grown diamond. The Tiffany T Smile pendant has no gemstone.

Is the Macy's pendant worth $199.00?

It is fair if a birthstone in 14k gold is what you want. Its 2.7 out of 5 rating from 100 buyers reflects complaints about size, chain strength and stone color, so check it in person if you can.

The Tiffany piece, on materials and buyer feedback. 18k gold is more durable than 14k, and the Macy's reviews flag a fragile chain.

How do the chain lengths compare?

The Tiffany chain adjusts from 16 to 18 inches. The Macy's chain is about 18 inches and fixed, and some buyers say it arrived shorter than advertised.

Which is better as a gift?

The Macy's pendant if the birthstone is the point, since it is personal and costs $199.00 as of October 31, 2026. The Tiffany pendant if you want a branded 18k gold piece in a Tiffany Blue Box.

Tiffany & Co. Tiffany T Smile Pendant in 18k Rose Gold vs Macy's Birthstone Pendant in 14k Gold or White Gold

Buy the Tiffany T Smile pendant if you want a solid 18k gold piece with a known maker and resale value. Buy the Macy's birthstone pendant if a personal birthstone matters more than metal weight and finish. The Macy's pendant is the cheaper of the two at $199.00 as of October 31, 2026; no current price was given for the Tiffany piece, so compare its live price before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent