Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat vs Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's
Buy the Tommy Hilfiger puffer if you want a casual, packable coat for mild winter days and the lowest price: $39.96 at Macy's as of October 28, 2026, against $140.00 regular. Buy the Summit 3-in-1 if you need real rain and snow protection and a fleece liner you can wear alone; it is $86.99. The puffer is the better value for city wear, the Summit the better tool for wet, active days.
Ask our shopping agent
Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat
4.6Choose the Tommy Hilfiger puffer if you want a lightweight, water-resistant hooded coat for fall and mild winter at about $40.
Pros
- Low price: $39.96 at Macy's, 71% off the $140.00 regular price
- Lightweight but warm enough for fall and mild winter
- Packable and machine washable
- Rated 4.6 out of 5 from 488 ratings
Cons
- Zipper breakage reported by several buyers
- Not made for extreme cold
- Hood does not lay flat; length called awkward by some
- Water resistant only, with no waterproof rating
What separates them
| Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat | Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $39.96 at Macy's as of October 28, 2026 | $86.99 |
| Waterproofing | Water resistant, no rating given | Waterproof shell rated 5,000 mm |
| Layering | Single puffer, midweight synthetic fill | 3-in-1: shell, fleece liner, or both zipped together |
| Warmth | Midweight, not built for extreme cold | Liner plus shell for cold and wet conditions |
| Hood | Fixed drawstring hood; buyers say it does not lay flat | Adjustable and removable hood |
| Pockets | Two side zip pockets | Four: two hand, one chest, one interior |
| Care | Machine wash | Hand wash only |
Price history
$65.99$39.96
- Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat: lowest $39.96 on Oct 28 at Macy's; $39.96 on Oct 30.
- Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's: lowest $65.99 on Nov 1 at Target.
Prices at every store
Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat
- LystCheck price at Lyst
- ModeSensCheck price at ModeSens
- PoshmarkCheck price at Poshmark
Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's
- veyoraCheck price at veyora
- TargetCheck price at Target
Specs compared
| Spec | Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat | Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Size XXS | — |
| Material | Polyester | — |
| With Hood | Yes | — |
| Fastener Type | Zipper | — |
| Color | Rouge | — |
| Style | Casual | — |
| Type | Puffer | — |
| For Rain | Yes | — |
| Packable | Yes | — |
| Size Type | Regular | — |
| Insulated | Yes | — |
What reviewers say
Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat
With 4.6 out of 5 from 488 ratings, owners mostly call the coat light but warm, comfortable and true to size, and many say it is good value on sale. The main complaints center on zipper durability and the hood and length.
Pros
- Lightweight yet warm
- Comfortable and stylish
- True to size
- Good quality coat and zippers for most buyers
Cons
- Zipper broke after a few wears
- Zipper quality issues reported
- Hood doesn't lay flat
- Length described as awkward
Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's
With 4.5 out of 5 from 262 ratings, owners largely report the jacket does its job for the price. Praise centers on the three-in-one flexibility and rain protection; complaints tend to focus on the hand-wash care and the shell's limits in heavy rain.
Pros
Questions and answers
- Which is warmer in real winter cold?
- The Summit. Its fleece liner zipped into the waterproof shell is built for cold and wet conditions. The Tommy Hilfiger puffer is midweight and buyers say it is not built for extreme cold.
- Which keeps me dry in rain?
- The Summit, with a waterproof shell rated 5,000 mm. The Tommy Hilfiger coat is water resistant only, with no stated rating.
- Is the Summit worth the extra money?
- If you face regular rain, snow or ski trips, yes: $86.99 buys waterproofing and three wearing setups. For dry city winters, the $39.96 puffer covers you for far less.
- Which is easier to care for?
- The Tommy Hilfiger puffer is machine washable. The Summit is hand wash only.
- Which fits better for layering?
- The Summit, since the liner and shell are made to be worn together, though you should size up for thick layers. The puffer has a relaxed fit but is a single layer.
- Which has the better hood?
- The Summit. Its hood is adjustable and removable. Buyers of the puffer complain the hood does not lay flat.
More comparisons
- Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's vs Port Authority Womens All Weather 3-in-1 Water Resistant Full Zip Hooded Jacket
- Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's vs Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka
- Calvin Klein Women's Stand Collar Lined Puffer Jacket vs Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat
- Big Chill Women's and Women's Plus Wide Quilted Puffer Coat with Faux Fur Trim Hood, Sizes S-3X vs Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's
- Tommy Hilfiger Women's Puffer Coat vs Patagonia Women's Down Sweater Hoody
- Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's vs WAGUTH Women's 2 in 1 Detachable Fleece Lined Hooded Jackets Waterproof Windproof Zip Up Coats with Pockets
- Calvin Klein Women's Stand Collar Lined Puffer Jacket vs Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's
- Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's vs Patagonia Women's Down Sweater Hoody
