Which is warmer, the Big Chill puffer or the Summit 3-in-1?

The Big Chill is warmer on its own. It is a heavyweight mid-length puffer with polyester fill. The Summit is warmest with the fleece liner zipped in, but its shell alone is a light rain layer.

Is the Summit 3-in-1 worth the extra money?

Yes if you deal with rain, snow or wind. The $86.99 Summit adds a 5,000 mm waterproof shell and three wearing modes. The $20.00 Big Chill is the better value for dry cold.

Which one is better for rain?

The Summit. Its outer fabric is rated waterproof to 5,000 mm, with a covered front closure and adjustable cuffs. The Big Chill puffer is not waterproof.

Does the Big Chill come in plus sizes?

Yes. It runs from S to 3X. The Summit 3-in-1 comes in standard women's sizes only, so check its size guide before ordering.

Which is easier to care for?

The Big Chill. It is 100% polyester and machine washable. The Summit is hand wash only.

Neither maker states a warranty. The Summit's technical shell and zippers suit hard outdoor use, while the Big Chill is a simple, low-cost puffer you can replace cheaply.

Big Chill Women's and Women's Plus Wide Quilted Puffer Coat with Faux Fur Trim Hood, Sizes S-3X vs Summit 3-in-1 Waterproof Jacket - Women's

Buy the Big Chill puffer if you want maximum warmth for very little money and need a plus-size fit up to 3X. Buy the Summit 3-in-1 if you face rain, snow or wind and want one jacket that works as a shell, a fleece or both. The Big Chill is $20.00 at Poshmark as of November 3, 2026, and the Summit is $86.99. The Summit costs about $67 more, and you pay that for waterproofing and three wearing modes, not for extra warmth.

Ask our shopping agent