Which is better for a two-acre lawn?

Both are rated for up to 2 acres. The Craftsman's 46-inch deck and 22 HP engine cover it faster, while the Toro's Smart Speed gives finer pace control.

Is the Toro worth the extra money?

At $5,189.99 at Zoro as of November 4, 2026 against $989.99 at Cool Gas Depot for the Craftsman, the Toro is hard to justify on mowing alone. Its case rests on Smart Speed, lighter weight and Toro's dealer network.

Which has the stronger engine?

The Craftsman. Its 22 HP Kohler 725 cc twin outpowers the Toro's 15.5 HP Briggs & Stratton 500 cc V-twin.

The Craftsman, down to 1 in versus 1.5 in on the Toro. Both top out at 4.5 in.

Do either come with a bagger?

The Craftsman listing includes a bagger. The Toro's bagger is optional, and its mulching kit is sold separately.

Which is easier to store?

The Toro, at 660 lb versus 710 lb for the Craftsman, and its 42-inch deck is narrower.

Toro TimeCutter 42-Inch Zero-Turn Riding Lawn Mower vs CRAFTSMAN Z5400 46-Inch Zero-Turn Riding Lawn Mower

The Craftsman Z5400 is the better buy for most homeowners. It has a bigger 46-inch deck, a stronger 22 HP Kohler engine, and costs $989.99 at Cool Gas Depot as of November 4, 2026, versus $5,189.99 at Zoro for the Toro as of the same date. The Toro TimeCutter 42-inch is a smaller, lighter machine with Smart Speed and a wide dealer network, but at that price gap it only makes sense if you specifically want Toro's pro-style controls and local service.

Today the CRAFTSMAN Z5400 46-Inch Zero-Turn Riding Lawn Mower costs $4,200.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.