Transitional 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set vs Westley Falls Extendable Counter Height Dining Set

Buy the Westley Falls if you host and need to seat more than four at times: its table extends from 60 to 80 inches with a removable leaf, and the pine-and-hardwood build with beaded trim reads more solid than the grey pub set. Buy the Transitional 5-Piece if your room is small and square: the 42-inch square table fits a nook and keeps conversation close, and owners report it feels sturdy, assembles in about half an hour with two people, and is easy to move for vacuuming. The Westley Falls wins on flexibility and materials; the Transitional set wins on footprint and simplicity.

• Choose the Transitional 5-Piece if you have a compact square nook, want a café-style counter set, and rarely seat more than four.
• Choose the Westley Falls if you entertain, want a table that grows to 80 inches, and prefer wood construction over a painted grey finish.