Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

5-Piece Dining Table Set for 4, Counter Height Modern Kitchen Table and Chairs Set of 4 with Storage Drawers, Marble Dining Table with 4 Upholstered Chairs for Small Space (Walnut) vs Transitional 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set with 42" Square Pub Table & X-Back Chairs

Buy the walnut marble set if you need drawers and want a softer, upholstered seat for long dinners in a tight nook. Buy the grey pub set if you want a proven 42-inch square table with wipe-clean faux leather seats and a sturdier, easier-to-assemble build. The marble set's price was not given; the grey set is $271.93 at BEL Furniture as of the listing date.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

5
5-Piece Dining Table Set for 4, Counter Height Modern Kitchen Table and Chairs Set of 4 with Storage Drawers, Marble Dining Table with 4 Upholstered Chairs for Small Space (Walnut)

5-Piece Dining Table Set for 4, Counter Height Modern Kitchen Table and Chairs Set of 4 with Storage Drawers, Marble Dining Table with 4 Upholstered Chairs for Small Space (Walnut)

Choose the walnut marble set if you want built-in storage drawers and upholstered chairs in a small dining space.

Pros
Built-in storage drawers keep small spaces tidy
  • Upholstered chairs are comfortable for long meals
  • Marble-finish top gives a modern look
  • Compact footprint suits tight dining areas
    • Cons
    • Fabric seats stain more easily than faux leather
    • Marble-look top needs careful wiping on spills
    • Walnut and marble finish may not suit every room
    • No published dimensions or assembly details
    T
    Transitional 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set with 42" Square Pub Table & X-Back Chairs

    Transitional 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set with 42" Square Pub Table & X-Back Chairs

    4.6· 8 ratings

    Choose the grey pub set if you want a 42-inch square table, wipe-clean faux leather seats and a set buyers describe as sturdy and quick to assemble.

    Pros
    • 42-inch square table seats four with room to spare
    • Padded faux leather seats wipe clean
    • Buyers report it feels sturdy and barely moves
    • Two people assemble it in about half an hour
    • Grey finish suits many decor styles
    Cons
    • No storage drawers
    • Wood X-back chairs are firmer than upholstered backs
    • Only 8 ratings so far

    What separates them

    5-Piece Dining Table Set for 4, Counter Height Modern Kitchen Table and Chairs Set of 4 with Storage Drawers, Marble Dining Table with 4 Upholstered Chairs for Small Space (Walnut)Transitional 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set with 42" Square Pub Table & X-Back Chairs
    TabletopMarble-finish topGrey finished square top
    Table shape and sizeNot specified; built for small spaces42" W x 42" D x 36" H square
    StorageBuilt-in drawersNone
    Chair seatUpholsteredPadded faux leather
    Chair backUpholsteredWood X-back
    CleanupMarble-look top and fabric seats need more care with spillsFaux leather wipes clean easily
    AssemblyNot specifiedNumbered, illustrated steps; about half an hour for two people
    PriceNot given$271.93 at BEL Furniture

    Price history

    • 5-Piece Dining Table Set for 4, Counter Height Modern Kitchen Table and Chairs Set of 4 with Storage Drawers, Marble Dining Table with 4 Upholstered Chairs for Small Space (Walnut): lowest $169.99 on Oct 29.
    • Transitional 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set with 42" Square Pub Table & X-Back Chairs: lowest $428.99 on Oct 29.

    Specs compared

    Spec5-Piece Dining Table Set for 4, Counter Height Modern Kitchen Table and Chairs Set of 4 with Storage Drawers, Marble Dining Table with 4 Upholstered Chairs for Small Space (Walnut)Transitional 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set with 42" Square Pub Table & X-Back Chairs
    Number Of Chairs—4 Chairs

    What reviewers say

    Transitional 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set with 42" Square Pub Table & X-Back Chairs

    Owners rate the set 4.6 out of 5 from 8 ratings. They describe it as sturdy and easy to move, and say assembly took about half an hour for two people.

    Pros
    • Feels sturdy; little movement or sound transfer
    • One adult can move it to vacuum underneath
    • Numbered, illustrated assembly with included tools
    • Color matches the photos
    Cons
    • Limited review count so far

    Questions and answers

    Which is better for a small apartment?
    Both are built for compact spaces. The marble set adds drawers, which saves room elsewhere. The grey set's 42-inch square table is open underneath, so chairs tuck in and the floor stays easy to vacuum.
    Which is easier to clean with kids?
    The grey set. Its faux leather seats wipe clean, while the marble set's upholstered chairs and marble-look top need more careful wiping after spills.
    Which set lasts longer?
    The grey set has buyer reports of feeling sturdy and barely transferring movement. The marble set has no published durability feedback, so the grey set is the safer bet.
    Is the grey set worth $271.93?
    Yes, if you want a full 42-inch square table and four chairs at that price. The marble set's price was not given, so compare it against $271.93 at BEL Furniture before deciding.
    Which is better for long dinners?
    The marble set, because its chairs are fully upholstered. The grey set's padded faux leather seats are comfortable but its X-back chairs are firmer.
    Do I need two people to assemble the grey set?
    Buyers say two people assembled it in about half an hour with the included tools. The marble set's assembly details were not given.