Which is better for wet trails?

The Biothane Montreal. It is waterproof and resists mold and mildew, so rain and mud wipe off. The Classic is leather and needs drying and conditioning after a soaking.

Which holds up to heavy pulling?

The Classic. Its double and stitched construction and over-the-neck strap are built for hard work in rough country. The Biothane model is a single strap aimed at trail use.

Do both fit the same horse?

Not exactly. The Biothane comes in horse size only. The Classic comes in cob and horse, with shoulder-to-center and center-to-girth measurements you can check against your horse.

Is the Classic worth extra money?

Only if you need the heavier build or the over-the-neck strap. If you mostly trail ride in wet weather, the Biothane model does the job with less upkeep.

Will either rub my horse?

Both have fleece at the chest tab, which is the main rub point. Fit matters more than material here, so check strap length against your horse.

Can I get brass hardware on both?

Yes. Both list brass hardware. The Classic also comes in chrome, and in black or brown.

Tucker Biothane Montreal Breast Collar vs Tucker Classic Montreal Breast Strap Breast Collar

Both are Tucker Montreal breast collars with 1-inch straps, brass hardware and fleece at the chest, so the choice comes down to material and fit. The Biothane model is the one to take into wet, muddy country because it will not soak up water or grow mold. The Classic is the one to take into rough brush and heavy pulling, where double-stitched leather and an over-the-neck strap hold up better. Check current prices at each store before you commit; the two are close in cost and move around.

Ask our shopping agent