Tucker Biothane Montreal Breast Collar vs Tucker Heritage High Plains Breast Collar
Buy the Biothane Montreal if you ride in rain, mud or daily and want tack you can hose off. Buy the Heritage High Plains if you want hand-tooled leather and a traditional look for shows and dry-country riding. No prices were provided for either collar, so check current store prices on this page before deciding.
Ask our shopping agent
Tucker Biothane Montreal Breast Collar
Choose the Biothane Montreal if you want a waterproof, low-maintenance collar for trail and wet weather.
Pros
- Waterproof and resistant to mold and mildew
- Fleece lining adds comfort on the shoulders
- Wipes clean after mud and rain
- 1-inch strap with brass hardware
Cons
- Synthetic look is not show-ring traditional
- Only one color and size listed
- No written warranty stated
What separates them
| Tucker Biothane Montreal Breast Collar | Tucker Heritage High Plains Breast Collar | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Beta BioThane (synthetic) | Leather, double ply |
| Water and sweat | Waterproof; resists mold and mildew | Leather needs drying and conditioning after wet rides |
| Maintenance | Wipe or hose clean | Clean and oil leather regularly |
| Look | Plain black with chrome and brass hardware | Hand-tooled Starry Plains border |
| Fit design | Sits on the shoulders; fleece lining | Contoured design |
| Hardware | Brass | Brass |
| Strap width | 1 inch | Not stated |
| Origin and warranty | Not stated | Made in the USA; no written warranty |
Price history
- Tucker Biothane Montreal Breast Collar: lowest $86.95 on Nov 1 at Golden Horseshoe Equestrian.
- Tucker Heritage High Plains Breast Collar: lowest $249.99 on Nov 1 at Walmart.
Prices at every store
Tucker Biothane Montreal Breast Collar
- Golden Horseshoe EquestrianCheck price at Golden Horseshoe Equestrian
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
Tucker Heritage High Plains Breast Collar
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- WalmartCheck price at Walmart
Specs compared
| Spec | Tucker Biothane Montreal Breast Collar | Tucker Heritage High Plains Breast Collar |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Beta BioThane | Leather |
| Color | Black Chrome | Black |
| Strap width | 1? wide | — |
| Size | Horse | — |
| Type | — | Shoulder, Neck |
| Brand | — | Tucker |
| Fastener type | — | Zipper |
| Pattern | — | Starry Plains border hand tooled |
| Has written warranty | — | No |
| Model | — | T360B |
| Pieces | — | 1 |
Questions and answers
- Which is better for trail riding in wet weather?
- The Biothane Montreal. It is waterproof and resists mold and mildew, so rain and mud wipe off. Leather like the High Plains needs drying and conditioning after a wet ride.
- Which lasts longer?
- Both are durable. BioThane does not dry out or crack and needs almost no care. Leather can last decades with regular cleaning and oiling, but neglects faster.
- Is the leather collar worth the extra care?
- If you want hand-tooled leather and a traditional look, yes. If you want tack you can hose off after every ride, the Biothane collar is the easier choice.
- Do both use brass hardware?
- Yes. The Montreal lists brass hardware, and the High Plains lists brass hardware as well.
- Which fits better on the shoulders?
- Both are shaped for shoulder fit. The Montreal is described as sitting on the shoulders with fleece lining; the High Plains uses a contoured cut.
- What size is each collar?
- The Montreal is listed in Horse size with a 1-inch strap. The High Plains listing does not state a size, so confirm sizing with the store before ordering.