Tudor Black Bay 58 vs Rolex Oyster Perpetual Datejust 41
Buy the Tudor Black Bay 58 if you want a rugged everyday dive watch at roughly half the price: $5,225 at Brown & Co. as of November 3, versus $11,395 at WatchGuys for the Datejust 41. Buy the Rolex Datejust 41 if you want a dressier watch with a date, a fluted white gold bezel and stronger resale. The Tudor wins on water resistance and value; the Rolex wins on finishing, brand and the date function.
Today the Tudor Black Bay 58 costs $7,195.00 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
Tudor Black Bay 58
Choose the Black Bay 58 if you want a 39mm dive watch with 200m water resistance, a timing bezel and a COSC/METAS-certified movement for about $5,225.
- 200m water resistance suits swimming and diving.
- 39mm case wears well on smaller wrists.
- COSC and METAS certification at this price is rare.
- T-fit clasp allows on-the-fly sizing.
- Costs about $6,170 less than the Datejust 41.
What separates them
| Tudor Black Bay 58 | Rolex Oyster Perpetual Datejust 41 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price (new, as of November 3, 2026) | $5,225.00 at Brown & Co. | $11,395.00 at WatchGuys |
| Case size | 39mm | 41mm |
| Water resistance | 200m | 100m |
| Bezel | Unidirectional steel with anodized aluminum insert | Fluted white gold |
| Date function | None | Date with Cyclops lens at 3 o'clock |
| Movement certification | COSC and METAS certified MT5400-U | Superlative Chronometer (COSC plus in-house testing) |
| Power reserve | 70 hours | About 70 hours |
| Bracelet and clasp | 3-link rivet-style steel with T-fit clasp |
Price history
- Tudor Black Bay 58: lowest $4,200.00 on Nov 3 at Amazon; $4,975.00 on Nov 4.
- Rolex Oyster Perpetual Datejust 41: lowest $11,395.00 on Nov 3 at WatchGuys.
Prices at every store
Tudor Black Bay 58
- Brown & Co.New
In stock
$5,225.00+ $25.00 shippingObserved Nov 3, 2026, 6:49 PM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$4,200.00Free shippingObserved Nov 3, 2026, 6:48 PM - Williams Jewelers of EnglewoodNew
Availability unknown
$4,975.00Observed at 7:43 PM
Rolex Oyster Perpetual Datejust 41
- WatchGuysNew
In stock
$11,395.00+ $100.00 shippingObserved Nov 3, 2026, 6:49 PM - ElegantSwissNew
In stock
$11,500.00Free shippingObserved Nov 3, 2026, 6:48 PM - luxurytimenyc.comNew
In stock
$11,875.00Free shippingObserved Nov 3, 2026, 6:48 PM
Specs compared
| Spec | Tudor Black Bay 58 | Rolex Oyster Perpetual Datejust 41 |
|---|---|---|
| Case Material | Steel | Oystersteel and white gold |
| Movement | Automatic | calibre 3235 |
| Bezel | Unidirectional | fluted |
| Crystal | Domed sapphire crystal | sapphire |
| Case Width | 39mm | — |
| Water Resistant | 200M | — |
| Power Reserve | 70 hour | — |
| Dial Colour | Black | — |
| Bracelet/Strap | Steel | — |
| COSC | Yes | — |
| Bracelet Length |
What reviewers say
Tudor Black Bay 58
Owners and reviewers consistently praise the Black Bay 58 for its wearable size, solid build and accurate in-house movement. Common complaints focus on the aluminum bezel and the vintage-style rivet bracelet.
- Comfortable 39mm case that wears well on most wrists
- Strong accuracy and long power reserve
- Good value among Swiss dive watches
- Secure T-fit clasp
- Aluminum bezel insert marks easily
- Rivet bracelet styling not to everyone's taste
- No date window
- Bracelet may be short for large wrists
Rolex Oyster Perpetual Datejust 41
Owner feedback on the Datejust 41 is largely positive, with buyers praising the finish, the movement and the buying experience. The one rating on this listing is 5 out of 5.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for swimming and diving?
- The Black Bay 58. It is rated to 200m and has a unidirectional timing bezel. The Datejust 41 is rated to 100m, which covers swimming but not diving.
- Is the Datejust 41 worth twice the price?
- Only if you value the date, the white gold fluted bezel and Rolex resale. On specs alone, the Tudor matches the 70-hour power reserve and adds 100m more water resistance for $6,170 less.
- Which lasts longer?
- Both are built to last decades with servicing every 5 to 10 years. The Tudor's aluminum bezel insert and the Rolex's fluted bezel both show wear; the Tudor's steel case and 200m sealing are more forgiving of hard use.
- Which fits a smaller wrist better?
- The Black Bay 58 at 39mm. The Datejust 41 is 41mm and wears larger, especially with its fluted bezel and Oyster bracelet.
- Does the Tudor have a date?
- No. The Black Bay 58 is time-only. If you want a date, the Datejust 41 has one magnified by the Cyclops lens.
- Which holds its value better?
- The Rolex Datejust 41. Rolex models generally depreciate less than Tudor on the secondary market, though neither is a guaranteed investment.