Is the Black Bay 58 worth $4,200?

At $4,200 it is near the low end of its recent range of $4,200 to $4,975. For a METAS-certified in-house dive watch with 200m water resistance, that is competitive.

How does it compare to the Black Bay 41?

The Black Bay 58 has a 39mm case and a thinner profile, while the Black Bay 41 is larger and heavier. The 58 suits smaller wrists and dressier wear better.

What is the power reserve?

The MT5400-U movement has a 70-hour power reserve, so it keeps running through a weekend off the wrist.

At 39mm it fits wrists from roughly 6 to 7.5 inches comfortably. Those used to 42mm divers may find it noticeably smaller.

What comes in the box?

The watch on its steel bracelet, along with Tudor's warranty card and documentation. Confirm the included items with the seller before ordering.

Its lowest recent price was $4,200 on November 3, 2026, against a high of $4,975. Prices on this model tend to move with retailer promotions rather than seasonal sales.

Where is the Tudor Black Bay 58 cheapest?

At Amazon, for $4,200.00, 16% under what the other stores charge, as of our latest check.

Where can I buy the Tudor Black Bay 58?

3 stores we checked sell it, including Williams Jewelers of Englewood, Brown & Co., Amazon.

Tudor Black Bay 58

Best price now

$4,200.00at AmazonObserved Nov 3, 2026, 6:48 PM

16% under what the other stores charge

Compared across 3 stores. Prices are checked against each store and labelled with when.

Visit Amazon

Ask our shopping agent

Our take on the Tudor Black Bay 58

The Tudor Black Bay 58 is a 39mm steel dive watch with a matte black dial, a unidirectional aluminum-insert bezel and 200m water resistance. It stands out for its compact case, a COSC- and METAS-certified in-house automatic movement with a 70-hour power reserve, and a rivet-style bracelet with the T-fit clasp. Its best new price of $4,200 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026 sits at the bottom of its recent range, which has run up to $4,975.

Best for

What reviewers say

Owners and reviewers consistently praise the Black Bay 58 for its wearable size, solid build and accurate in-house movement. Common complaints focus on the aluminum bezel and the vintage-style rivet bracelet.

Pros

Comfortable 39mm case that wears well on most wrists
Strong accuracy and long power reserve
Good value among Swiss dive watches
Secure T-fit clasp

Cons

Aluminum bezel insert marks easily
Rivet bracelet styling not to everyone's taste
No date window
Bracelet may be short for large wrists

About the Tudor Black Bay 58

39mm steel case, Steel braceletCASE: 39mm stainless steel case with polished and satin finishesBEZEL: Unidirectional rotatable bezel in stainless steel with anodized aluminum insertMOVEMENT: Manufacture Caliber MT5400-U (COSC and METAS certified) Self-winding mechanical movement with bidirectional rotor systemDIAL: Matte black, domed, with applied hour markersWINDING CROWN: Stainless steel screw-down winding crown with the TUDOR rose in reliefCRYSTAL: Domed sapphire crystalWATERPROOFNESS: Waterproof to 200m (660 ft)BRACELET: 3-link rivet-style stainless steel bracelet with polished and satin finishes with TUDOR T-fit cl