Valencia Artisan Leather Sofa vs Downey Cognac Leather Sofa

Buy the Valencia if you want a softer, pillow-back sofa with removable, washable cushion covers and leather pitched as pet-scratch resistant. Buy the Downey if you want a firmer, channel-tufted mid-century look on a kiln-dried beech frame with Pirelli webbing. Both use full-grain Italian leather in cognac. The Valencia has far more owner feedback and a 4.9 rating; the Downey has thinner review coverage and a few reports of scratches on arrival.

• Choose the Valencia Artisan if you want removable cushion covers, a plush fiber-filled back, and leather built to shrug off pet claws.
• Choose the Downey if you want a firmer foam seat, a channel-tufted mid-century profile, and a webbed beech frame.