Valencia Artisan Leather Sofa vs POLY & BARK Canale Leather Sofa

The Valencia Artisan is the better-built, more comfortable everyday sofa: Italian Nappa top-grain leather, an alder wood frame, high-resiliency foam with fiber-wrapped backs, and removable cushion covers that make cleaning realistic. The POLY & BARK Canale is the style pick: a 99-inch channel-tufted tuxedo silhouette with a low back and a 750 lb capacity that seats three to four. Owners of the Valencia praise the soft leather, easy assembly and pet resistance; the Canale's fixed channel tufting looks sharp but leaves less room to rotate or clean cushions.

• Choose the Valencia Artisan if you want a softer, deeper-seated leather sofa with removable covers, a taller back and a frame built to last.
• Choose the POLY & BARK Canale if you have a long wall or open room and want a low, wide channel-tufted statement piece that seats three to four.