Valour 98" Leather Sectional Sofa vs Barton Tan Leather Right Facing Sectional Sofa

The Barton is the better pick for a large family room: it seats 5 to 6, adds an extended chaise, and its steel-reinforced wood frame and reversible cushions suit daily use. The Valour is the better pick for a smaller apartment or a mid-century room, with top-grain leather, biscuit tufting, and a compact 98-inch footprint. Owners praise the Barton's looks and easy assembly, but some report color mismatches between pieces and no help after the return window. The Valour's boxed shipping makes it easy to move in, but assembly is required and the back is low at 14.5 inches.

• Choose the Valour if you have a smaller room, want top-grain leather with mid-century tufting, and need a sofa that ships in a box you can carry upstairs.
• Choose the Barton if you need seating for 5 to 6, want a chaise to stretch out on, and prefer reversible cushions and a steel-reinforced frame.