Barton Tan Leather Right Facing Sectional Sofa vs Costco Leather Power Reclining Sectional

The Barton is the better pick if you want a big, stationary leather sectional with a long chaise and a made-in-USA frame. The Costco is the better pick if you want power reclining seats and a modular six-piece layout. The Barton's corrected-grain buffalo leather and steel-reinforced wood frame are solid for the class, and owners praise the look and easy assembly, though one buyer got mismatched colors and several got no help after the 30-day window. The Costco's power recline and gray leather suit movie-room use, but its listing gives few build details, so check the frame and cushion construction before you commit.

• Choose the Barton if you want a long right-facing chaise, reversible cushions and a stationary sofa you can stretch out on.
• Choose the Costco if power reclining seats and a six-piece modular layout matter more to you than a chaise.