DealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Vanilla Bean Protein Powder vs Clean Simple Eats Cake Batter Protein Powder

Both are flavored whey-based protein powders with no added sugar, but they are built for different shoppers. The Vanilla Bean has a detailed, third-party-tested label with 22 g protein, 4 g fiber and 160 calories per scoop, and 4,985 ratings averaging 4.8. The Cake Batter's only price on record is $29.99 on October 29, 2026, and its label details are not given here, so it is the harder one to judge. Buy the Vanilla Bean if label transparency and a mild vanilla-cinnamon flavor matter; buy the Cake Batter if you want a dessert flavor and that $29.99 price is the one you can get.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

V
Vanilla Bean Protein Powder

Vanilla Bean Protein Powder

4.8· 4,985 ratings

Choose the Vanilla Bean if you want a third-party-tested, no-sugar-added powder with 22 g protein, 4 g fiber and a clean vanilla-cinnamon flavor you can also bake with.

Pros
  • 22 g protein and 4 g fiber per 160-calorie scoop
  • No added sugar, no sucralose, no aspartame, no sugar alcohols
Four protein sources including grass-fed New Zealand whey
  • Third-party tested; gluten-free and soy-free
  • Reviewers call it smooth, easy to mix and gentle on the stomach
    • Cons
    • Only 21 servings per 1.85 lb tub
    • 300 mg sodium per scoop
    • Contains both whey and casein, so not dairy-free
    • Vanilla-cinnamon flavor is mild, not a dessert flavor
    Clean Simple Eats
    Clean Simple Eats Cake Batter Protein Powder

    Clean Simple Eats Cake Batter Protein Powder

    Choose the Cake Batter if you want a dessert-style flavor and the $29.99 price recorded on October 29, 2026 fits your budget.

    Pros
    • Cake batter flavor is a dessert-style option
    • $29.99 was the recorded price on October 29, 2026
    • Marketed as a protein powder with no added sugar
    Cons
    • Protein, calorie and ingredient details are not stated in the listing
    • No third-party testing claim shown
    • No shopper rating shown
    • Only one price point on record, so no sense of how it moves

    What separates them

    Vanilla Bean Protein PowderClean Simple Eats Cake Batter Protein Powder
    Flavor profileVanilla bean with a hint of cinnamonCake batter
    Protein per serving22 gNot stated in the listing
    Calories per serving160Not stated in the listing
    Added sugarNone; no sugar alcohols or artificial sweetenersNot stated in the listing
    Protein sourcesGrass-fed whey, casein and pea, four sourcesNot stated in the listing
    Third-party testingYes, stated on the labelNot stated in the listing
    Recorded priceNot given here$29.99 on October 29, 2026
    Shopper ratings4.8 of 5 from 4,985 ratingsNot given here

    Price history

    $29.99$29.99
    Oct 29Nov 2
    • Vanilla Bean Protein Powder: lowest $29.99 on Nov 2 at TheBetterHealthStore.com.
    • Clean Simple Eats Cake Batter Protein Powder: lowest $29.99 on Oct 29 at Clean Simple Eats; $29.99 on Nov 2.

    Prices at every store

    Vanilla Bean Protein Powder

    • Crystal Coast Sport ShopCheck price at Crystal Coast Sport Shop
    • eBayCheck price at eBay
    • TargetCheck price at Target
    Prices and history →

    Clean Simple Eats Cake Batter Protein Powder

    • KnoxSuppsCheck price at KnoxSupps
    • TargetCheck price at Target
    • The Vitamin ShoppeCheck price at The Vitamin Shoppe
    Prices and history →

    Specs compared

    SpecVanilla Bean Protein PowderClean Simple Eats Cake Batter Protein Powder
    FormPowder—
    FlavorVanilla—
    Meal ReplacementYes—
    IngredientsProtein, Amino Acids—
    Amino Acid TypeBCAA—
    Protein TypeWhey, Casein, Pea—
    Sugar ContentNo Sugar Added—
    Protein Grams Per Serving22 g per serving—
    Net contents1.85 Pound(s); 840 Gram(s)—
    Serving size40 Gram(s) [1 scoop]—
    Servings per container21—
    Calories160 Calorie(s)—
    Show all 20 specsShow fewer specs
    SpecVanilla Bean Protein PowderClean Simple Eats Cake Batter Protein Powder
    Protein25 Gram(s)—
    Total fat2.5 Gram(s)—
    Saturated fat0.5 Gram(s)—
    Total carbohydrates6 Gram(s)—
    Dietary fiber4 Gram(s)—
    Sodium300 mg—
    Iron6 mg—
    Calcium20 mg—

    Questions and answers

    Which is better for muscle gain?
    The Vanilla Bean states 22 g protein per scoop from whey, casein and pea, which fits a post-workout or meal-replacement use. The Cake Batter's protein content is not stated in the listing, so you cannot compare gram for gram from what is shown.
    Which one is better if I have a sensitive stomach?
    Vanilla Bean reviewers report it is gentle on the stomach, and it uses no synthetic gums or emulsifiers. The Cake Batter's ingredient list is not given, so there is less to go on.
    Is the Cake Batter worth $29.99?
    That was its only recorded price, on October 29, 2026. Whether it is worth it depends on its protein and calorie numbers, which are not stated in the listing, so compare the per-serving protein against the Vanilla Bean's 22 g before deciding.
    Which has less sugar?
    The Vanilla Bean is labeled no sugar added and uses no sucralose, aspartame or sugar alcohols. The Cake Batter's sugar content is not stated in the listing.
    Can I bake with either one?
    Just Ingredients says the Vanilla Bean blends into smoothies, baked goods and recipes, and reviewers use it in yogurt and overnight oats. Baking performance for the Cake Batter is not described.
    Which lasts longer per tub?
    The Vanilla Bean gives 21 servings of 40 g each from a 1.85 lb tub. The Cake Batter's serving count and tub size are not stated, so a per-serving cost comparison is not possible yet.

    Buying guides that pick them

    • Best protein powders with clean ingredients