Black FridayDealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresResearchTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026:TVsLaptopsHeadphonesAppleGamingVacuumsKitchenToysSmartwatchesTabletsFurnitureMattresses

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Sheet Pan vs Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet

These are different tools, not close substitutes. The Vollrath N5300 is a commercial full-size pan (26 x 18 in, 14 gauge) for sheet-pan dinners, roasting and batch baking on a standard baker's rack; the Chicago Metallic is a small 13 x 9 in textured cookie sheet for home ovens. At the latest prices, the Vollrath is $31.91 at eBay as of November 6, 2026, and the Chicago Metallic is $15.00 at eBay as of November 6, 2026. Buy the Vollrath if you have rack space and cook in volume; buy the Chicago Metallic if you bake cookies in a normal home oven.

Today the Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet costs $16.91 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Vollrath
Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Full Size Natural Finish Aluminum Sheet Pan

Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Sheet Pan

Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Full Size Natural Finish Aluminum Sheet Pan

5(1 rating)
$31.91at eBayVerified
Visit store

Choose the Vollrath N5300 if you want one heavy-duty full-size pan for roasting vegetables, sheet-pan meals and large batches, and your oven or rack fits 26 x 18 in.

Pros
  • Heavy 14 gauge aluminum resists warping at high heat
  • Concave bottom flattens as it heats for even browning
  • Closed bead and reinforcing rod add rigidity
  • Stacks with other full-size pans
  • Large surface handles big batches
Cons
  • 26 x 18 in will not fit most home ovens
  • Warranty does not cover household use
  • Bare aluminum stains and reacts with acidic foods
  • Hand wash only
  • Sold in case packs of 6 in some listings
Chicago Metallic
Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet

Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet

4.5(6 ratings)
$15.00at eBayVerified
Visit store

Choose the Chicago Metallic if you bake cookies and small batches in a standard home oven and want a light, textured pan that releases easily.

Pros
  • Small size fits standard home ovens
  • Textured surface helps release cookies and roasted food
  • Light and easy to handle
  • Half the price of the Vollrath
  • Uncoated aluminum browns well
Cons
  • Thin compared with the Vollrath and can warp at high heat
  • Small surface limits batch size
  • Not dishwasher safe
  • No stated warranty
  • Uncoated aluminum needs hand washing and can discolor

What separates them

Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Sheet PanChicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet
SizeFull size, 26 x 18 in13 x 9 in
Gauge and weight14 gauge aluminum, 4.35 lb1.0 mm heavy-gauge aluminum, much lighter
SurfaceNatural finish, non-perforated, closed beadTextured uncoated aluminum
Oven fitFits standard commercial baker's racks; too big for most home ovensFits standard home ovens
Stacking and storageTapered design stacks neatly with other full-size pansSingle small pan, easy to store
CleaningHand wash; bare aluminum reacts with acidic foods and darkensHand wash recommended, not dishwasher safe
Warranty1-year parts and labor, void for household useNo stated warranty
Price$31.91 at eBay as of November 6, 2026$15.00 at eBay as of November 6, 2026

Price history

  • Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Sheet Pan: lowest $48.72 on Nov 6 at Walmart.
  • Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet: lowest $11.99 on Nov 1 at Fleet Farm.

Prices at every store

Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Sheet Pan

  • WalmartNew

    In stockSold by Restaurant Essentials

    $48.72Free shippingObserved at 3:13 AM
    Visit store
  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownSold by kandinoff (100% positive, 1,400 ratings)Returns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.

    $31.91Free shippingVerified
    Visit store
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $52.04Free shippingObserved at 3:13 AM
    Visit store

Also available at

  • eBayCheck price at eBay
  • WalmartCheck price at Walmart
All 3 stores and price history →

Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet

  • eBayNew

    Availability unknownSold by howmuchwillugiveme4it (99.7% positive, 6,300 ratings)Returns: Set by the eBay seller; the eBay Money Back Guarantee covers an item that doesn't arrive or isn't as described.

    $15.00+ $27.45 shippingVerified
    Visit store

Also available at

  • Fleet FarmCheck price at Fleet Farm
Prices and history →

Specs compared

SpecVollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Sheet PanChicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet
colorSilverSilver
sizeFullNo information
Length26.00" in13 in
Width18.00" in9 in
Height1.00" in1.04 in
MaterialAluminum—
Gauge14 Gauge—
Pan SizeFull—
FinishNatural finish—
StyleNon-Perforated—
SeriesWear-Ever®—
Weight4.35—
Show all 17 specsShow fewer specs
SpecVollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Sheet PanChicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet
Case Pack6—
Warranty1-year Parts & Labor—
Material Type—Metal, Aluminum, Heavy gauge, 1.0mm aluminum
Dishwasher Safe—No (Hand wash recommended)
Design Highlights—Textured

What reviewers say

Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Sheet Pan

Owners of Wear-Ever pans generally report they hold up through heavy use and bake evenly. The common complaints are about cleaning bare aluminum and its reaction to acidic ingredients.

What people mention
  • BuildPraisedOwners say the thick gauge stays flat and survives years of use.
  • Even heatingPraisedThe flattening bottom is credited with consistent browning.
  • CleaningCriticisedBare aluminum must be hand washed and can stain.
  • Acidic foodsCriticisedTomatoes and citrus can discolor or pit the surface.

Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet

Rated 4.5 out of 5 from 6 ratings. Owners of this style of uncoated textured pan generally report even baking and sturdy build, with cleaning and staining as the main complaints.

Pros
  • Even browning across the pan
  • Sturdy, warp-resistant feel
  • Texture helps release cookies
Cons
  • Hand washing is a chore
  • Surface can stain or discolor over time

Questions and answers

Which is better for sheet-pan dinners?
The Vollrath N5300. Its 26 x 18 in surface and 14 gauge aluminum hold a full meal of vegetables and protein without warping. The Chicago Metallic is too small for that.
Will the Vollrath fit my home oven?
Usually not. At 26 x 18 in it is sized for standard commercial baker's racks. Measure your oven interior first; most home ovens take an 18 x 13 in pan like the Chicago Metallic.
Which lasts longer?
The Vollrath. At 14 gauge with a closed bead and reinforcing rod, it is built for commercial use and resists warping far better than the 1.0 mm Chicago Metallic.
Is the Vollrath worth the extra money?
Only if you need the size and durability. At $31.91 versus $15.00 as of November 6, 2026, you pay for commercial gauge and capacity, not for better cookies.
Which is better for cookies?
The Chicago Metallic. Its textured surface releases cookies cleanly and its size suits a home oven. The Vollrath works for large batches but is overkill for a dozen cookies.
Can either go in the dishwasher?
No. Chicago Metallic recommends hand washing, and bare aluminum like the Vollrath's darkens and pits in a dishwasher. Wash both by hand.

More comparisons

  • Wearever Aluminum Baking Sheet vs Vollrath N5300 Wear-Ever Full Size Natural Finish Aluminum Sheet Pan
  • Wearever Aluminum Baking Sheet vs Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet