Wearever Aluminum Baking Sheet vs Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet
Buy the Chicago Metallic if you want a durable, uncoated pan that browns evenly and lasts for years. Buy the Wearever if you want a non-stick surface that releases cookies and roasted vegetables without parchment. No prices were provided for either pan, so compare current store prices on this page before deciding.
Ask our shopping agent
Wearever Aluminum Baking Sheet
Choose the Wearever Aluminum Baking Sheet if you want a non-stick sheet pan for easy release and quick cleanup.
Pros
- Non-stick surface releases cookies and roasted food without sticking
- Easier cleanup than bare aluminum
- Good for sticky or delicate foods
Cons
- Coating can scratch and wear with metal utensils
- Coating may limit high-temperature use
- Size not specified
What separates them
| Wearever Aluminum Baking Sheet | Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet | |
|---|---|---|
| Surface | Non-stick coating | Uncoated bare aluminum |
| Release and cleanup | Food releases easily; wipe or light wash | Needs grease or parchment; hand wash only |
| Durability | Coating can scratch, peel or wear over time | 1.0mm heavy-gauge aluminum resists warping |
| Browning | Coating slows browning slightly | Textured bare aluminum browns cookies and crusts evenly |
| Dishwasher | Not specified; hand washing protects the coating | Not dishwasher safe; hand wash recommended |
| Size | Size not specified | 13 x 9 x 1.04 in |
| High-heat use | Coating limits safe maximum temperature | Bare metal handles high oven heat |
Price history
- Wearever Aluminum Baking Sheet: lowest $35.99 on Nov 1 at Amazon.
- Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet: lowest $11.99 on Nov 1 at Fleet Farm.
Prices at every store
Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet
- Fleet FarmCheck price at Fleet Farm
Specs compared
| Spec | Wearever Aluminum Baking Sheet | Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet |
|---|---|---|
| Material | Aluminum | — |
| Non-Stick | Yes | — |
| Type | Sheet Pan | — |
| Material Type | — | Metal, Aluminum, Heavy gauge, 1.0mm aluminum |
| Dishwasher Safe | — | No (Hand wash recommended) |
| Size | — | No information |
| Length | — | 13 in |
| Width | — | 9 in |
| Height | — | 1.04 in |
| Color | — | Silver |
| Design Highlights |
What reviewers say
Chicago Metallic Uncoated Textured Aluminum Cookie/Baking Sheet
Rated 4.5 out of 5 from 6 ratings. Owners of this style of uncoated textured pan generally report even baking and sturdy build, with cleaning and staining as the main complaints.
Pros
- Even browning across the pan
- Sturdy, warp-resistant feel
- Texture helps release cookies
Cons
- Hand washing is a chore
- Surface can stain or discolor over time
Questions and answers
- Which pan is better for cookies?
- The Chicago Metallic. Its textured bare aluminum browns cookies evenly and won't warp at high heat. The Wearever's non-stick coating is convenient but browns a little slower.
- Which is easier to clean?
- The Wearever. Its non-stick surface wipes clean, while the Chicago Metallic needs hand washing and often grease or parchment to prevent sticking.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Chicago Metallic. Its 1.0mm heavy-gauge aluminum has no coating to peel or scratch, so it holds up over years of use.
- Can I put the Chicago Metallic pan in the dishwasher?
- No. Chicago Metallic recommends hand washing, and dishwasher detergent can discolor bare aluminum.
- Is the Wearever pan good for high-heat roasting?
- Check its maximum temperature first. Non-stick coatings typically have a lower heat limit than bare aluminum, which handles high oven heat fine.
- What size is the Chicago Metallic pan?
- It measures 13 x 9 x 1.04 inches, a standard quarter-sheet size that fits most home ovens.