Which fits a bigger TV?

The homfan. It is rated for screens up to 80 in, against 70 in for the Whalen. The Whalen's 58 in console is listed for most 68 in TVs.

Which heats a room better?

The Whalen, on paper. Its fireplace is rated 1,500 W and 5,200 BTU for up to 1,000 sq. ft., with a thermostat and timer. The homfan's listing gives no output figures.

Is the Whalen worth $199 more?

Only if you need real room heat and the swappable door inserts. If you mainly want a stand for a large TV, the homfan does that for $269.99.

Which is better for a 75 in TV?

The homfan. A 75 in screen exceeds the Whalen's 70 in maximum, while the homfan is rated to 80 in.

Do both have cabinets?

Yes. The Whalen has two cabinets plus an open shelf, and the homfan has cabinets under a 36 in fireplace. Only the Whalen's doors swap between glass and wood.

Which has more reviews?

The Whalen shows 4 ratings at 5 out of 5. The homfan listing shows no rating count, so neither has a large review base to judge reliability.

Whalen Coriander Fireplace TV Console vs homfan 70 Inch TV Stand with 36 Inch Electric Fireplace

Buy the homfan if you want the most screen size and storage for the money: $269.99 at Macy's as of November 4, 2026, versus $469.00 at The Home Depot for the Whalen. Buy the Whalen if you want a 1,500-Watt heater rated for up to 1,000 sq. ft., a remote, and glass or wood door inserts. The homfan saves about $199 but gives up the stated heating coverage and the swappable door panels.

Today the homfan 70 Inch TV Stand with 36 Inch Electric Fireplace costs $199.01 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.