Winco Trash Receptacle Lid, Green - PTCL-23GR vs Rubbermaid Brute 32 Gallon Trash Can Lid

Buy the Winco PTCL-23GR lid only if you already own a Winco PTC-23GRC 23-gallon slender can and want a hands-free swing top. For everything else, the Rubbermaid BRUTE lid is the more versatile buy: it fits standard 32-gallon BRUTE cans, sheds rain through self-draining channels, and resists UV and dents. The Winco is a niche fitment with a counterbalanced swing flap; the Rubbermaid is a flat snap-lock lid built for outdoor commercial use. Owners of the BRUTE lid call it a solid, well-fitting replacement made of thick plastic, though not perfect.

• Choose the Winco PTCL-23GR lid if you own a Winco PTC-23GRC 23-gallon slender can and want hands-free, odor-trapping swing disposal.
• Choose the Rubbermaid BRUTE lid if you need a weatherproof flat lid for a 32-gallon round outdoor can that won't pool water.