Winco Trash Receptacle Lid, Green - PTCL-23GR vs PRO-SOURCE Round Lid for 44 Gal Trash Cans

These are not interchangeable lids, so the real question is which can you own. The Winco PTCL-23GR is a rectangular dome swing lid made only for the Winco PTC-23GRC 23-gallon slender can; the PRO-SOURCE is a round gray lid for Huskee 44-gallon cans (MSC4445). Buy the Winco if you already own or plan to buy the Winco can and want hands-free, odor-trapping swing action. Buy the PRO-SOURCE if you have a Huskee 44-gallon round can and just need a replacement lid. Neither is a step up in build quality; both are basic molded plastic, and the Winco's swing mechanism is the more useful feature.

• Choose the Winco PTCL-23GR if you own the Winco PTC-23GRC 23-gallon slender can and want a counterbalanced swing lid that closes itself and traps odors.
• Choose the PRO-SOURCE round lid if you have a Huskee 44-gallon round can (MSC4445) and need a plain gray replacement lid.