Pfaltzgraff Winterberry 32-Piece Dinnerware Set vs Corelle Winter Frost White 50-Piece Set

Buy the Corelle Winter Frost White if you want a light, tough, everyday set that stacks small and survives drops. Buy the Pfaltzgraff Winterberry if the holiday pattern is the point and you want serving pieces included. Corelle's Vitrelle glass resists chips and cracks and carries a 3-year limited warranty, and its 4.8 rating from 657 ratings edges Winterberry's 4.5 from 451. Winterberry is heavier stoneware with a 1-quart vegetable bowl and a 14 x 10-1/2 inch platter; owners love the look but some report uneven piece quality and breakage in transit.

• Choose the Winterberry if you want a festive holly pattern for holiday tables and a set that already includes a vegetable bowl and oval platter.
• Choose the Corelle Winter Frost White if you want a lightweight, chip-resistant white set for daily use that stacks in half the space of ceramic dishes.